The Electric State: A Mixed Reception for Netflix's $320 Million Gamble

Netflix's ambitious sci-fi epic "The Electric State" has become one of the streaming giant's most polarizing releases of 2025. With its massive $320 million budget, star-studded cast led by Millie Bobby Brown and Chris Pratt, and direction from Marvel veterans the Russo brothers, the film has generated significant discussion among critics and viewers alike.

Critical Response: A Resounding Thumbs Down

The critical consensus on "The Electric State" has been overwhelmingly negative. The film currently holds a dismal 15% on Rotten Tomatoes and a "generally unfavorable" 29/100 on Metacritic16.

Elizabeth Vincentelli of The New York Times delivered a particularly scathing assessment, noting that while Simon Stålenhag's original graphic novel was "narratively elliptical, chromatically subdued, and melancholy," the film adaptation is "obvious, noisy, and just plain dumb"8. Courtney Howard from Variety criticized the film for abandoning the source material's strengths in favor of "trite notions about freedom, preachy commentary on prejudice, and tired, clichéd conflicts between humans and robots"1.

Other common criticisms include:

Emotional hollowness: Many critics found the emotional moments contrived and lacking authenticity
Pacing issues: At 2 hours and 20 minutes, several reviewers felt the film dragged considerably
Wasted potential: Critics lamented how the impressive visual world-building wasn't matched by compelling storytelling

Audience Reaction: A Different Story

Interestingly, general audiences have been considerably more forgiving. The film quickly shot to #1 on Netflix's charts upon release and maintains a respectable 6.1/10 on IMDb26. User reviews reveal a more positive sentiment:

"It was a fun and different movie. Not life-changing but enjoyable."1

"The visual effects are impressive and the action is fun. If you like Chris Pratt's humor, it's worth watching."1

"I don't understand the hate. It's a solid sci-fi adventure with some genuinely touching moments."1

Many viewers specifically praised Millie Bobby Brown's performance, the robot designs, and the film's visual aesthetic while acknowledging the narrative shortcomings.

Visual Achievement vs. Storytelling Failure

Even the harshest critics have acknowledged the film's technical accomplishments. The post-apocalyptic American landscape, filled with retro-futuristic technology and war machine remnants, creates a visually distinctive world. The robot designs, particularly Michelle's companion "Skip," have been widely praised for their creativity and emotional expressiveness12.

However, this visual prowess ultimately highlights the screenplay's weaknesses. As one Reddit user put it: "It's like they spent $300 million on the visuals and $20 million on the script." The film struggles to develop meaningful character arcs or explore its themes of technology addiction and human connection with any real depth4.

Netflix's Strategy: Critics Be Damned

Industry analysts suggest Netflix may not be overly concerned with the critical drubbing. Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy's movies editor, observed: "If this was a theatrical release, bad reviews might have impacted attendance, but on Netflix, it's likely to do very well"6.

This follows Netflix's established pattern with big-budget spectacles. Their previous blockbuster "Red Notice" scored just 39% with critics but earned a 92% audience score and 231 million views. The streaming model prioritizes initial viewership over critical acclaim, and star power combined with visual spectacle often drives those numbers regardless of quality6.

Conclusion: Spectacle Over Substance

"The Electric State" ultimately represents the growing divide between critical assessment and streaming success. While film critics have valid concerns about the narrative and emotional depth, many viewers are content with the visual spectacle and star performances.

The film serves as yet another data point in the ongoing conversation about what constitutes "success" in the streaming era, where traditional metrics of quality and box office performance have been fundamentally transformed.

Meta description: An in-depth analysis of Netflix's $320 million sci-fi blockbuster 'The Electric State', exploring its critical reception, audience response, and what it reveals about the streaming giant's content strategy.

SEO tags: The Electric State, Netflix movie, Millie Bobby Brown, Chris Pratt, Russo brothers, sci-fi film, robot revolution, dystopia, movie review, 2025 films

TastyMovie

Discover the Magic Behind 'Wicked' - 91% on Rotten Tomatoes!